| Model | Scorpion Winter | Pilot Alpin PA3 |
| Tread pattern photos |  |
 |
| Price range | Check on Amazon Check on DiscountTire | Check on Amazon Check on DiscountTire |
| Brand | Pirelli | Michelin |
| Car type | SUV and 4x4 | Passenger Car / Crossover |
| Category | Winter Premium Touring tires | Winter High Performance tires |
| Tires scores compare | ||
| Overall | 83.3% | 86.3%  |
| Overall Dry | 83.7% | 91.3% |
| Corner Stability | 82% | 90% |
| Dry Traction | 86% | 93% |
| Steering Response | 82.5% | 91% |
| Overall Wet | 86% | 91% |
| Hydroplaning resistance | 92% | No data |
| Wet Traction | 86% | 91% |
| Snow performance | 84% | 70% |
| Light Snow | 94% | No data |
| Heavy Snow | 87% | No data |
| Ice | 82% | 60% |
| Overall Comfort | 84% | 95% |
| Ride Comfort | 90% | No data |
| Overall Noise | 86% | No data |
| Wear (tread life) | 78.5% | 92% |
| Buy again | 80% | 95% |
| Price range | Check on Amazon Check on DiscountTire | Check on Amazon Check on DiscountTire |