All-season tire Updated September 2026

Toyo A23 review

Name: Toyo A23
Brand: Toyo

Relative score from owner reviews only Provisional

Owners 50 · 11 reviews analysed

How scores work

Check price on Amazon · A23 Compare with another tire

Add your size for an exact match

Width/AspectRRim

The Amazon link then searches this exact size.

TireWheelGuide may earn a commission from purchases made through these links.

Toyo A23 has a Relative Score of 56 out of 100 among all-season tires. 11 owner reviews rate it 50 out of 100. 50% would buy it again.

What owners say

No road-test results yet, so every score here comes from owner reviews found online.

How scores work

Relative score: 0–100. Blends road tests (60%) and owner reviews (40%) category by category, the same way on every TireWheelGuide page. With only one of the two, the missing half is estimated from it, so the score stays closer to average. It needs at least one road test or five owner reviews.
Road tests: 0–100 per score, from published tests, newer tests counting more. Each result is compared with every other tire in the same test, so a win against a strong field counts for more. The average tested tire gets 70, the best 100; with only one or two tests a tire stays nearer 70. The discipline rows show % of the best tire in that test.
Owner reviews: 0–100 from the owner reviews we found online, adjusted for how generously each site rates and scaled like the road tests: the average tested tire gets 70. With only a few reviews a tire stays near the average.

Full methodology

By owner reviews

50/100

From 11 owner reviews analysed, scaled like the road tests: the average tested tire gets 70.

Would buy again 50%

Dry

Overall dry

Corner stability

Dry traction

Steering response

Wet

Overall wet

Wet traction

Snow & ice

Overall snow & ice

Comfort

Overall comfort

Treadwear

Overall treadwear

Handling

Overall handling

Own these tires? Write a review →

What owners like and dislike

Themes extracted from 11 owner reviews found online.

The Toyo A23 receives polarized reviews, functioning adequately as an OEM tire for highway and dry conditions while drawing severe criticism for its performance and longevity from a significant portion of users. While some drivers report respectable tread life and competent off-road capability on heavier vehicles, others highlight concerning traction issues in wet weather and rapid, unexpected wear.

Pros

Solid grip and stability in dry conditions and on the highway
Capable off-road and in muddy tracks for 4x4 vehicles
Reasonable comfort and low road noise for some drivers
Acceptable OEM longevity for certain CUV and fleet drivers reaching over 40,000 miles

Cons

Dangerous and slippery performance on wet surfaces and roundabouts
Disappointing tread life and rapid wear reported by multiple users
High road noise noted by some drivers
Poor value for money compared to higher-quality aftermarket alternatives

Worth knowing

Drivers of larger 4x4 and SUV models, such as the Shogun Sport, reported mixed experiences ranging from excellent off-road traction to severe wet-weather slippage.
CUV and crossover owners (such as the Mazda CX-5) experienced varying tread wear, with some achieving respectable OEM mileage up to 44,000 miles while others experienced premature wear.